16 septembre 2021
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ , info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Gregory Dart, « 3. Beethoven: Revolutionary Transformations », Open Book Publishers, ID : 10670/1.icnwop
This chapter investigates Fidelio’s relation to the French Revolution by looking at it as the last of a series of revisitings of a revolutionary ‘spot of time’. First laid out by Bouilly and Gaveaux’s 1798 rescue opera, Léonore, ou L’Amour Conjugal (1798), which was supposedly based on a true story of the Jacobin Terror, this ‘spot’ was then returned to, and reworked, by several European composers of the early nineteenth century, who produced operas with the same plot, most notably Beethoven, whose Leonores of 1805 and 1806, and Fidelio of 1814 betray a subtly unstable perspective on recent revolutionary history. Lastly, this chapter looks at the role of melodrama in Beethoven’s opera, not only as a curious technical innovation, but also as a new means of conceiving of, and dramatising, historical action, and argues that one way of seeing the dénouement of 1814 is as an essentially conservative attempt to bury the traumatic vision of history—of history as sforzando—that its earlier incarnations had opened up.