Philosophising on international law: Jovanović’s conception of normativity and rationality

Fiche du document

Date

23 novembre 2020

Discipline
Type de document
Périmètre
Langue
Identifiant
Source

Revus

Organisation

OpenEdition

Licences

All rights reserved , info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess


Mots-clés

legal authority practical reason conceptions of agency rationality in law normativity in law philosophy of international law pravna avtoriteta praktični razlog pojmovanja delovanja racionalnost v pravu normativnost v pravu filozofija mednarodnega prava


Citer ce document

Veronica Rodriguez-Blanco, « Philosophising on international law: Jovanović’s conception of normativity and rationality », Revus, ID : 10.4000/revus.6461


Métriques


Partage / Export

Résumé En Sl

In his book The Philosophy of International Law, Jovanović advances the view that an inquiry into the reasons regarding why states would consider international norms as binding norms would be part of a sociology of law, and we can infer that, for him, it is a part of an inquiry into an empirical order. I advance two criticisms of one aspect of Jovanović’s conclusion on empiricism: a) the idea that there is a plurality of reasons for actions that constitute a wide spectrum, from self-interested reasons to moral reasons and, b) that we can understand the plurality of reasons for actions of either states or citizens through empirical research. I argue that these positions reflect a particular and, in my view, problematic view of agency.

Filozofiranje o mednarodnem pravu. Jovnovićevo pojmovanje normativnosti in racionalnosti. V svojem delu The Philosophy of International Law, Jovanović zagovarja stališče, da preučevanje razlogov, zaradi katerih države štejejo mednarodne norme kot zavezujoče norme, spada v sociologijo prava. Iz tega lahko sklepamo, da je zanj to del preučevanja empiričnega reda. Avtorica v tem besedilu predstavi dve kritiki enega vidika Jovanovićevega zaključka o empiricizmu: prvič, idejo, da obstaja širok spekter razlogov za ravnanje, ki gredo od sebičnih razlogov do moralnih razlogov; drugič, da lahko razumemo mnoštvo razlogov za ravnanje tako držav kot državljanov skozi empirično raziskovanje. Avtorica trdi, da ta stališča kažejo partikularen in problematičen vidik agentstva.

document thumbnail

Par les mêmes auteurs

Sur les mêmes sujets

Sur les mêmes disciplines

Exporter en