Fiche du document
1 janvier 2021
- handle: 10670/1.dxgbmz
Sujets proches
Africa, South Legislative acts Legislative enactments Acts, Legislative Enactments, Legislative Laws (Statutes) Judgement Case ProofCiter ce document
Thulisile Brenda Njoko, « The admissibility of criminal findings in civil matters: Re-evaluating the Hollington judgment », De Jure, ID : 10670/1.dxgbmz
Métriques
Partage / Export
Résumé
In Hollington v Hewthorn & Co Ltd 2 1943 All ER 35 it was held that a finding of a criminal court did not have any probative value in a subsequent civil action and was inadmissible as evidence. Despite the case being one of English origin, the South African courts have largely adopted this ruling as one grounded in our common law. In this paper, the judgment in the Hollington case is critically analysed in order to determine its continued applicability in the face of South Africa's existing law of evidence and the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 ("the Constitution"). It is argued that in light of the existing law, this rule no longer finds application in South Africa.