Fiche du document
2002
Copyright PERSEE 2003-2023. Works reproduced on the PERSEE website are protected by the general rules of the Code of Intellectual Property. For strictly private, scientific or teaching purposes excluding all commercial use, reproduction and communication to the public of this document is permitted on condition that its origin and copyright are clearly mentionned.
Sujets proches
Family history Family trees Genealogies Kazikumuktsy (Dagestan people) Laktsy (Dagestan people) Lakh (Dagestan people) Lakk (Dagestan people) Lakhs (Daghestan people) Árboles genealógicos Linaje Lakks Laki Kazi Kumukh Kizi Kumuk Laqs Lakhs Ghazi Kumuq Qazi Qumukh Kazikoumouks Lakcy Lakkuchus Laktsy Kazikumuktsy Ghazi Qumuq Ghazi Kumukh Kazikumyks Méthodes comparatistes Méthode comparatiste Comparaison, Méthodes de Comparatisme Méthodes de comparaison Comparative, Méthode Méthodes comparatives Analyse comparative Science des gènes Science de l'hérédité Science du gène Descendants (généalogie) Recherches généalogiques Aïeux Descendance Ascendance Postérité Lignée Ancêtres Arbre généalogiqueCiter ce document
Bernard Laks, « Le comparatisme : de la généalogie à la génétique. », Langages, ID : 10.3406/lgge.2002.2399
Métriques
Partage / Export
Résumé
The comparatist framework which have undergone a remarkable development in the 19th century and have declined in the 20th century, has recently made a noticeable come back on the international scientific scene. The mixing of the comparatist and reconstructivist perspective with population genetics lead to the so called "new synthesis". The same uncontrolled metaphors and the same genealogical conceptions are set to work in this new framework. We first introduce a critical analysis of classical comparatism stressing how and why the genealogical notion of Stammbaum was deconstructed. We then show how modern genetic comparatism rests on the very same ideas without having answered the critics addressed to the classical one. Finally, we show that within a neo Darwinian paradigm many fruitful alternatives to the genetic-genealogical framework exists which allows for new ways of questioning diachronic relations among languages