Renewable electricity producing technologies and metal depletion: A sensitivity analysis using the EROI

Résumé En

More and more attention is being paid to renewable technologies because they are seen as a great opportunity to disengage our society from its dependence on fossil fuels. Such flow-based energy resources that rely on solarenergy are supposed to lead us toward a sustainable energy future. However, because of their high capitalintensity, renewable technologies require large amounts of matter, including both common and rare metals.These metals require energy for their production, and more specifically for their extraction. The energy costassociated with metal extraction is linked to mineral ore grade, meaning that as depletion progresses, energycost increases. In addition, renewable energy resources deliver less net energy to society compared to fossilfuels, because of their diffuse nature. It is therefore easy to see that a close relationship exists between energyand metal sectors. In this article, we describe more precisely this relationship by investigating how the energyrequirement associatedwith metal extraction could impact the energy-return-on-investment (EROI) of differentrenewable and nuclear technologies.More precisely,we present a methodology that can be used to calculate thesensitivity of the EROI of a given technology to a specific or to multiple metal ore grade degradation. We foundthat if considered separately, the qualitative depletion of a given metal has no significant impact on the EROIof renewable and nuclear technologies, unless its concentration approaches very low grade. However, if allmetals are considered together, the EROI of these same technologies could be importantly diminished, especiallyif they tend to very low concentrations.