Quod Erat Expectandum: The Modus Operandi of Models and Quantifications. GI_Forum|GI_Forum 2018, Volume 1 |
Fiche du document
22 juin 2018
- ISIDORE Id: 10670/1.54d164...
- issn: 2308-1708
- doi: 10.1553/giscience2018_01_s274
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Mots-clés
912,singularity of numbers, framed analysis, reductionism, models as creators of realities,GeographySujets proches
Standard of value Scientific research Science research Science--Research Case Use of Methods of analysis Analysis and chemistry Analytical methods Chemical analysis Analysis methods Analysis and examinationCiter ce document
Andreas Koch, « Quod Erat Expectandum: The Modus Operandi of Models and Quantifications. GI_Forum|GI_Forum 2018, Volume 1 | », Elektronisches Publikationsportal der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschafte, ID : 10.1553/giscience2018_01_s274
Métriques
Partage / Export
Résumé
Models and quantitative analyses deal with numbers. In general, numbers have a very specific meaning in that they represent a phenomenon as idiosyncratic (singular) in a way that words cannot do. However, the quality as well as the quantity of a phenomenon must be considered in order to understand its nature more comprehensively. Furthermore, the use of both numbers and terms incorporates presuppositions about what is perceived as relevant and valuable, which is not usually evidently visible – their existence is realized through reductionism. The reduction of a phenomenon to a number, therefore, does not neglect its intrinsic value. As is the case with terms, models and quantities are jeopardized by being instrumentalized in scientific research and political debates. ‘Quod erat expectandum’ thus has a twofold meaning: (i) Models and quantifications are expected to create a reality rather than simply represent it. They are used to grasp the world(s) that surround(s) us. (ii) Models and quantifications are expected to reduce complexity. This methodologically and epistemologically built-in mechanism is – in a positive as well as in a critical sense – inevitable.
