Fiche du document
1 janvier 2016
- ISIDORE Id: 10670/1.64c52b...
Ce document est lié à :
10.5294/PEBI.2016.20.1.6
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Mots-clés
Objective ethics bioethics infertility applied ethics ethical evaluation ontologically-grounded personalism principlism preference utilitarianismSujets proches
AssessmentCiter ce document
Luca Valera et al., « AN ETHICAL DILEMMA IN THE FIELD OF GYNECOLOGY », Persona y Bioética, ID : 10670/1.64c52b...
Métriques
Partage / Export
Résumé
The aim of this paper is to assess a case report in the field of gynecology, starting from an ethical paradigm that relates primarily to the so-called "sources of morality" (objective structure, circumstances, aim). In order to do so, we first will present four ethical paradigms for the evaluation of clinical cases (preference utilitarianism, principlism, ontologically-grounded personalism and Aristotelian/Thomist objective ethics). After introducing the main aspects of these paradigms and pointing out that what matters in an ethical evaluation is not so much the final judgement, but rather the argument that leads to it, we will assess the case report in light of the chosen paradigm. Lastly, we will outline a possible solution to the problem, starting from the previous ethical evaluation.
