Fiche du document
26 mars 2018
- handle: 10670/1.awp73q
- hal: hal-02565378
- doi: 10.1515/mp-2018-0006
Ce document est lié à :
info:eu-repo/semantics/altIdentifier/doi/10.1515/mp-2018-0006
info:eu-repo/semantics/OpenAccess
Mots-clés
microstructuralism constitution multiconstituted function causal role chemistry causal profile substance natural kindSujets proches
IdentityCiter ce document
Max Kistler, « Natural Kinds, Causal Profile and Multiple Constitution », HAL-SHS : histoire, philosophie et sociologie des sciences et des techniques, ID : 10.1515/mp-2018-0006
Métriques
Partage / Export
Résumé
The identity of a natural kind can be construed in terms of its causal profile. This conception is more appropriate to science than two alternatives. The identity of a natural kind is not determined by one causal role because one natural kind can have many causal roles and several functions and because some functions are shared by different kinds. Furthermore, the microstructuralist thesis is wrong: The identity of certain natural kinds is not determined by their microstructure. It is true that if A and B have the same microstructural composition then a sample of a chemical substance A is of the same chemical substance as a sample of B. However, the reverse does not hold. It is not the case that if a sample of a chemical substance A is of the same chemical substance as a sample of B then A and B have the same microstructural composition. This is because a macroscopic NK can be "multiconstituted" by different microstructures.