Societies without citizens: The Anomic Impacts of Labor Market Restructuring and the Erosion of Social Rights in Europe

Résumé En

This article studies the chronic and acute anomic social impacts of the development of market societies in Europe over past decades. Focusing on the firm but linking micro and macro levels, it argues that the passage from the Welfare State to disembedded markets and neoliberal governance has generated individual and collective anomie by depriving social actors of agency and voice while caging them in the disciplinary constraints of an ideal competition society. Promoted by public and private governors animated by visions of managerial omnipotence, this reconfiguration has hollowed out the cluster of rights that founded democratic and social citizenship in Europe. The article discusses the manifestations of anomie, stressing the violence flowing from the radical uncertainty to which atomized employees and more broadly citizens are confronted in the face of the reification of collective goals, which have been reduced to participation in market society. Drawing on the classical literature (Durkheim, Parsons, Merton) but expanding upon it, the paper examines exit solutions, at individual and collective levels, involving violence against the self (suicide) and others (mobbing, xenophobia, fascism), and concludes that Europe seems to be heading towards a protracted period of danger laden chronic and acute anomie.